WRE News August 5, 2023
Buyer
The housing supply has fallen to a historic low. Builders have not been able to keep pace with demand, resale stock is in short supply due to many social and economic factors, and the demand for housing from the millennial generation continues, with a younger generation of Zoomers right behind them.
Affordability at all levels remains a challenge, the diversity of housing stock as means of allowing greater affordability continues to be a problem, and public officials are searching for answers in zoning, construction, tax credits, and repurposing of commercial office space as a means to boost supply and affordability. All of these efforts are important, but there may be, yet another means of restoring harmony and balance to this supply equation.
What we are proposing is a moratorium of two years at the federal level on the capital gains tax for real estate as a possible means for increasing supply, easing demand, offering more opportunity and selection, and just perhaps, returning appreciation to a more acceptable norm.
The Boomer generation is one of the wealthiest and has a lot of investment property, much of which falls into the affordable housing range, under $1.2 million in urban and metro areas. Many (not all) are hanging onto this property because of the 15% capital gains tax at the federal level, combined with the 5% capital gains tax at the state level, and a depreciation tax on top of this, making selling too expensive and egregious.
By having a finite period of two years in which to financially motivate these individuals to sell, the housing market could be made to resemble a four- to five-month supply and force the market to return to some level of normalcy. This solution, however, must be implemented with considerable care and oversite so as to avoid flooding the marketplace and causing another housing recession.
There would need to be a set of parameters that the moratorium would follow:
At each four-month interval during the two years, the program would be re-assessed for its efficacy. The parameters would be re-evaluated to ensure they are not producing a deluge of homes coming to market, nor a shortage. The numbers could be adjusted up or down, or not at all, based on what the national housing data is showing.
The program could be regulated by the Department of Housing and Urban Development, which would have the right to change the parameters if the program needs to be accelerated or decelerated based on the number of homes coming to market or languishing on the market; it could do so by issuing a change at the end of each fourth-month cycle. Because real estate is hyperlocal, each state would have the right to end participation at the end of each six-month interval during the two-year moratorium.
While this program could be very successful for some states suffering from a lack of inventory, it could be potentially catastrophic for the sun and sand states of California, Nevada, Arizona, and Florida which have a larger number of seniors living in them, as well as investment properties. By allowing the individual states to have control over the implementation of the program, it would help to mitigate the risk of flooding the market and manage the intended results of the program.
There are definitely more parameters or control measures that might be added, or considered, but this paper is only intended to spark imagination, debate, and just maybe implementation and passage at the federal and state levels if deemed appropriate. So, thank you for reading, and I hope to hear back from you. All input and feedback are appreciated.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
September 18, 2024
September 17, 2024
MICHELIN announced a second wave of top picks for the best hotels in the U.S. and also revealed its selections for a prestigious group of luxury hotels in Canada and M… Read more
September 17, 2024
Generation Z—currently aged 15 to 29—is growing up, and the eldest are ready to rent their own home.
September 17, 2024
A shift is underway in the housing market this season.
September 16, 2024
Running is having quite the moment right now.
September 16, 2024
From financial challenges to work stressors, there are countless pressures on modern marriages.
We Guide Homeowners through the complicated process of selling their home using our 4 Phase Selling Process and 3 Prong Marketing Strategy that alleviates their stress and moves them effortlessly to their next destination. Schedule a 15 Minute Complimentary Strategy Session Today